As mentioned before, this is a work in progress that will be added to as reviews are discovered and experience is had.
Feel free to offer comments on trainers listed or not!
- Little Beetle Learners.Absorbency is comparable to Gerber training undies. Pull up style, no pocket for adding absorbency. I like the wide, flat leg and waist elastic as opposed to the tight, bunched elastic on other brands.But, be aware of the snaps! They will leave marks on your child. Poor Sterling had horrid impressions!Better for Babies, the company that makes Little Beetle, has closed it’s doors. However, there are still many trainers on the market if you are interested. Little Beetle Learners are very soft, as they are made of organic velour cotton. They do not contain any PUL so don’t count on them holding much but solids.The side snaps do make it easy to take off in the event of a solid accident.I enjoyed reading the review written on the Earthy Crunchy Mama Blog.
- Otter Puddles
I really liked my Otter Puddles- they have cute colour combos, they look just like undies, the range of sizes goes down really small (I think they would be good for EC), they have (adjustable) snaps at both hips, and an optional booster. They wouldn’t keep the bed from getting wet, they will feel damp on the outside if there is an accident, but as long as you change soon they should keep clothes dry (to be honest I’m not 100% sure on that, I always put my dd in skirts or dresses when potty training). In any case, I figure that if your ‘training pants’ are able to keep the bed dry, it’s actually a slip on/off diaper, not training pants! ~Emily D.
- Super Undies. Super Undies are one of the most recommended trainers among experienced cloth diaper moms (as observed from forums and Facebook groups). Super Undies have a great size range. If you have a older, large or special needs child the size large will accommodate where most other brands don’t.
Super Undies pocket trainers are designed to look like big kid undies. They have snaps in the back to remove them in the case of a messy accident, but the front looks more like underwear than a diaper. There is just enough absorbency sewn in to catch a small accident, but you can add step up inserts to provide enough absorbency to last through a car ride or other extended wear. Three sizes with two waist settings each will fit even big kids. The trainers are fairly trim with the sewn in soaker only, but adding inserts gives them more of a fluffy, diaper-like look. ~Maria
Maria wrote a great review of Super Undies Pocket Potty training pants that I highly recommend.
Super Undies produced this video to show you how their pocket trainer works.
- Snap-Ez Pocket Trainers. If you have a special needs older child or adult, Snap-Ez is the best option for you. Cloth diapers and trainers in adult sizes are much harder to come by. I get several inquiries a year for recommendations in this area. If you are shopping for an adult you will shop the Snap-Ez pocket diapers. This is because you are most likely looking for something with more absorbency than a “trainer”.
- Tinkle Time Trainers by Ladder Hill Designs. Tinkle Time Trainers is a pattern available for purchase. There are many different styles that can be seen here: Tinkle Time Pocket Trainer Pattern. Review written for All About Cloth Diapers by Audi D.
I purchased this pocket trainer (PUL outer, bamboo velour inner) for at night for my 4 year old potty trained son. I wanted something that could be pulled up and down easily, as he sometimes wakes up at night to go to the bathroom on his own. He still is a very heavy wetter at night.
After discussing some options with the lovely lady, Hope, we decided on a nighttime trainer with her bamboo insert and doubler set. I purchased the size 4T, my son weighs 38lbs and wears mostly size 4 clothing. The trainer with the doubler set comes to about $25 total.
I was curious about using zorb, as I heard it’s good for heavy wetters so she offered to sew zorb in the inner layer of the inserts for me. She is a wonderfully helpful lady! When I received the package in the mail (about 2 weeks from the time I ordered until I received it in the mail, from the US to Canada!)
I was surprised at how large and substantial the insert seemed, and how well the trainer was sewn. VERY VERY good quality and lots of bang for your buck! It went through the prewash beautifully. The first night I tried it I also put in small fuzzibunz minky insert as a doubler. When trying it on my son the first time he said it was very soft and comfortable. It’s also quite a bit more trim than any other trainers I’ve looked at (SuperUndies, Happy Heiny’s)
My son is VERY picky about what he wears, he would NOT wear cloth of any kind before this. I put him to bed and surprise! His sheets and pj’s were completely dry in the morning. He sleeps 12 hours at night. 2nd time I tried it he was still dry. The 3rd we had a leak… I’m not sure why as the insert wasn’t saturated, but I was ready to try again anyways… the 4th and 5th time I tried it we had no leaks! Fit is very important in these trainers, and Hope sewed them exactly to the right specifications.
On the whole I am very pleased with this trainer, honestly I have no idea what could be improved on, all the reviews I’ve read rave about these, and I agree!
Hope is simply THE BEST lady I’ve ever dealt with, (in my limited experience) and if you are looking to invest in trainers (night or day) she is the lady to call!
- Underwear. No absorbency, hard to clean up poop accidents. However, easy transition and cheapest. I’ve used underwear for potty training 4 children and, aside from 1 child who makes everything interesting, it has been a smooth experience. I’m sure I change sheets more than someone who uses cloth trainers but overall I have found the system to be successful.